If Your Workplace Culture Could Speak, What Would It Tell You Its Job Is?
Let me be clear about what this piece is not describing. It’s not the everyday uncertainty that comes with change or employees who simply need context, communication and reassurance. Those people are part of a healthy culture’s natural rhythm.
This is about the undercurrent no one wants to talk about – the pockets of dysfunction that linger because they serve someone’s advantage. I’m referring to the part of culture that never makes it onto posters.
Walk into any workplace and you’ll see values on the wall: integrity, commitment, mission, trust. Yet none of those posters tell the real story about culture.
What actually shapes culture is what gets protected, tolerated or quietly hidden behind the scenes. Inside every organization is a group no one publicly talks about, but every leader privately knows exists – the culture contrarians. These are the people who don’t actually want culture to improve because the dysfunction benefits them.
This is the topic most leadership training avoids.
If you want real culture cohesion, you have to understand who’s in the room and why they behave the way they do.
1. Many People Don’t Want Culture to Change
A workplace culture shift threatens those who benefit from the ways things have always been. Not everyone wants clarity, collaboration or accountability. Some people benefit from noise. Some from ambiguity. Some from staying frustrated enough to avoid responsibility. Some enjoy being the emotional gravity point – the one everyone tiptoes around because it creates a false sense of control.
A workplace culture can be understood through four archetypes. Each one highlights how they use their voice and also how they might be seen in a pressure situation.
Culture Builders
In meetings, Culture Builders use their voice to reinforce alignment and fairness. They speak up for what serves the team, not just themselves. They name the benefits of change even when it’s uncomfortable, support leadership when decisions move the organization forward and say the steady, grounded thing that others are thinking but hesitant to voice. Builders also notice people. They acknowledge effort, call out progress and reinforce what the culture actually values in real time.
When pressure increases, Culture Builders stabilize the room. They stay grounded rather than reactive, contain emotion without dismissing it and keep conversations focused on purpose and next steps. They don’t escalate tension or retreat into silence. Their steadiness quietly gives others permission to stay aligned.
Culture Tolerators
In meetings, Culture Tolerators often speak last or not at all. When they do contribute, their comments are neutral, agreeable or procedural. They track the emotional temperature of the room and adjust accordingly. Their silence isn’t apathy, it’s adaptation (and survival).
When pressure increases, Culture Tolerators default to self-protection. They avoid visible positions and wait for clarity before committing. While they rarely create disruption themselves, their lack of engagement allows stronger voices to dominate. Over time, this quiet compliance normalizes whatever behavior leadership consistently tolerates.
Culture Resisters
In meetings, Culture Resisters slow momentum. They raise concerns without offering solutions, revisit decisions that were already made or emphasize why something won’t work based on past failures. Their tone sounds practical, but it carries an undercurrent of skepticism that drains energy and dampens enthusiasm.
When pressure increases, accountability for Culture Resisters gets reframed as unfair treatment or being “singled out.” Leaders are pulled into managing reactions instead of advancing work. The behavior becomes less about resolution and more about active gratification through disruption, where slowing productivity and consuming leadership attention restores their sense of control.
Culture Saboteurs
In meetings, Culture Saboteurs are often measured and careful. They may appear supportive, ask thoughtful questions or withhold strong opinions publicly. They rarely challenge leadership directly and often look reasonable on the surface.
When pressure increases, their influence moves out of sight. Culture Saboteurs reinterpret decisions within side conversations, selectively share information and quietly shape narratives that create doubt or division. When confronted, they may engineer complexity by reframing feedback as retaliation or positioning themselves as a target. The payoff comes from power gained by hijacking attention. As leaders are pulled into damage control, trust erodes and disruption becomes a tool rather than a byproduct.
2. The Workplace Culture Isn’t About Values – It’s About Power
Values look great in onboarding packets.
Culture however, can be defined by who gets rewarded, who gets forgiven, who gets listened to and who gets protected.
Culture doesn’t derail because people misunderstand expectations. It derails because someone benefits from the way things currently operate and that others fear speaking up.
These hidden influence lines shape behavior far more than any stated value ever will. Integrity is what your people have been waiting for.
Integrity is what your people have been waiting for.
3. The Culture Isn’t The Average – It’s The Outliers
Culture is shaped more by extremes than by the majority. People don’t adjust to the average. They adjust to the loudest, the most unpredictable or the most protected.
Outliers set the emotional barometer. They reveal how safe it actually is to speak, disagree or lead.
Your outliers expose your culture’s true operating system.
4. The Culture Has A Shadow Side – and Leaders Don’t Like Admitting It
Every positive culture has tradeoffs if not balanced. High performance can lead to burnout. Collaboration can delay decisions. Supportive cultures can drift into conflict avoidance. Innovation without execution becomes vision without traction.
Not all contrarians are destructive. Some protect the organization. Others protect themselves.
The mark of leadership maturity is knowing how to differentiate between the two – and addressing each without avoiding discomfort.
5. The Edgiest Truth – Aligned Culture Requires Time And Honest Interpretation
Healthy culture cohesion doesn’t begin with new initiatives or pep talks. It begins with time – time to pause, assess and interpret what’s actually happening beneath the surface.
It requires honesty. The willingness to admit that unhealthy issues exist, even if you’ve learned to tolerate or work around them. It demands noticing unproductive habits, unspoken loyalties and ego protections that quietly shape behavior.
Every culture has relics that persist simply because “they’ve always been this way.” Most people no longer remember why they exist, only that challenging them feels risky. That’s where stagnation hides.
Cohesion begins when leaders stop absorbing dysfunction, see clearly, and act with intention.
Tips:
Noticing the Culture Resisters and Culture Saboteurs
Notice who gets away with important mistakes.
Who shifts the room’s energy the moment they walk in?
Who becomes suddenly quiet when accountability enters the conversation?
Who benefits from keeping the culture exactly where it is?
Who derails progress with side comments or subtle resistance?
Prompts that Reveal Truth
What part of the existing culture do you personally benefit from, even if it frustrates others?
Which outlier on your team reveals something your culture doesn’t want to examine?
What pattern have you been tolerating that no longer aligns with who you want to be as a leader?
What complaints or rumors about mistreatment have you heard but not addressed?
Who seems energized when leaders are pulled into managing conflict instead of advancing work?
Who controls how decisions are interpreted after meetings end?
Consider This:
Cultural cohesion isn’t a team-building exercise. It’s a power recalibration. It’s about protecting people and protecting the organization. It’s the consistency of speaking up, addressing dissent fairly and leaders being willing to listen, validate and act.
Closing thought
When dysfunction is allowed to persist and grow, things will eventually reach a moment where the habit of adapting becomes too uncomfortable.
The quiet majority usually wants integrity, not the louder patterns of dysfunction that create fear and silence around them. Healthy cohesion begins when even one leader stops protecting dysfunction, names what others avoid and moves toward healthier alignment anyway.
That single act of quiet clarity often breaks the old pattern and starts the new one – reminding people that better days are possible when leaders protect the culture, not the chaos.
This isn’t a topic you resolve in one post, so we’ll stay with it and continue examining it in the posts ahead.
Leading forward,
Michelle
Bridging The Gap - where insight leads to impact.
Before you move on, consider this an invitation into a different kind of space – one that allows ideas to settle and perspective to widen before action resumes. It reflects my ongoing commitment to thoughtful, grounded leadership and greater clarity. Welcome to Cognitive White Space.
A monthly reminder that thinking requires space.
Cognitive white space is not idle time and it is not optional. It’s the condition required for clear thinking. Without it, urgency masquerades as productivity and busyness replaces meaning.
Cognitive white space is where thinking widens, concepts settle, and insight has room to surface. Decisions may still be made quickly, but perspective shrinks and creativity narrows. It’s not that those decisions are ineffective, but they’re made within a narrower frame, before broader impact, innovation, and downstream effects have time to be considered.
That broader level of impact emerges only when the human system slows down enough for ideas to connect and possibilities to form beyond what arrives on demand. Stress compresses thinking; space expands it. Protecting cognitive white space with the same intention you protect other critical priorities is an investment in clarity, something that strong leaders leverage to create steadier decisions and more durable outcomes.
I look forward to using this space to challenge the familiar refrain, “I don’t have time to think.”
A more honest question might be, “How is that working for me, and can I afford not to make room for it?”
Because The Heart Of Every Great Organization Still Beats Human.™
-Michelle Ogle, Bridge Executive Coaching
TARGET LEADERSHIP ACUMEN!
Leadership Under Pressure
Executive coaching that helps leaders refine their presence and think clearly under pressure in order to create meaningful impact in complex environments.
Claim Your Courtesy Offer
Culture Conversation
Michelle is offering a courtesy in-person session to organizations within San Luis Obispo County. She brings enthusiasm and fresh perspectives and opens the door to renewed possibility.
Drawing on her human-centered approach to leadership and workplace culture, Michelle highlights:
The meaning of connection and synergy
Navigating AI in a human world
Reigniting purpose
Motivation and drive - have you found yours?
Can your people use a fresh spark?
Claim your courtesy in-person Culture Conversation and discover how to reignite purpose, momentum, and meaning in your workplace.
Michelle C. Ogle, M.A., Executive Coach, Organizational Consultant
Michelle blends human-centered insight with psychology-informed leadership and behavioral strategies to help executives lead with clarity, composure, and grounded confidence. Her work consistently opens new pathways for possibility, performance, and connection.